• By Kevin E. Noonan —

    The human tendency to identify with tribes of "like" humans (related by family, place of origin, or religion, among other bases) was perverted during the Twentieth Century (and in some places remains so today) into the idea of "purity" along racial lines.  The foolishness of this thinking, insofar as it is based on genetic relatedness, has been debunked recently by a wealth of scientific evidence, explicated thoroughly in David Reich's book, Who We Are and How We Got Here: Ancient DNA and the New Science of the Human Past.

    These researches have not reached any sort of completion, and last week, a group of authors* published a paper in Cell entitled "Paleolithic to Bronze Age Siberians Reveal Connections with First Americans and across Eurasia" which sets forth further genetic evidence of the relationship between Bronze Age Siberian populations and early North Americans (as well as evidence of Yersinia pestis co-migration with its human hosts).

    Prior work had shown the existence of an Ancient North Eurasian (ANE) (24,000 yo individual) showing a genomic ancestry "widespread" across Siberia during the Paleolithic (extending until ~8,500 BCE); the contributions of this genomic pattern can be found in both present-day Eurasians and Native Americans.  There is extensive genetic, anthropological, and historical evidence that Siberia was the source of multiple migrations into North America that resulted in colonization and population of both North and South American beginning 25,000 – 20,000 years ago, millennia before European colonization in the second millennium A.D.  This prior work did not definitively establish the Siberian population or populations responsible for these migrations.  This uncertainty is complicated by the cultural and genetic changes associated with population movements during the transition from the Neolithic to the Bronze Age, particularly from the steppes in Easter Eurasia which the authors characterize as being "largely unexplored."

    Here, these researchers performed genome-wide analysis from 19 Upper Paleolithic to Early Bronze Age unrelated individuals (4 females, 15 males) from the Lake Bailal region in Siberia.  In addition, analysis of Y. pestis found associated with the tested human samples, which evidence supports migration from the western steppes as contributing to these Siberian populations.  These 19 samples included one from an Upper Paleolithic person (dated from 14,050-13,077 before the present day, BP); four individuals from the Early Neolithic (7,320  – 6,500 BP); and 14 late Neolithic individuals (4,830 – 3,570 BP) from ten different archeological sites:

    Image A
    The DNA used in these studies were from teeth and portions of temporal bone prepared as single-stranded and double-stranded libraries that were subject to shotgun sequencing.  Endogenous DNA amounts ranged from 0.12-50.54%; these libraries were enriched for human DNA (there being some contaminating non-human DNA almost always in such libraries) using human-specific SNPs targeting comprising 1.24 million variable sites and then sequenced to provide 0.04X – 2.07X coverage of the human genome.  "Pseudo-haploid" genotypes were determined by random sampling of a single allele at each position in the pseudo-haploid genotype, covering 34,000 – 886,000 SNPs.  Further, these authors report performing "deep" shotgun sequencing of 8 individuals with "high endogenous DNA levels" (defined as 12-51%) and finally refined these individuals' diploid genotypes by comparison of 386,000 – 518,000 SNPs to the Human Origins dataset and with 3,014 modern (present day) genotypes and 453 ancient human DNA samples.

    The genetic background of the individuals was assessed by Principle  Component Analysis, which revealed admixture of genotypes from Northeast Asian ancestry from the Russian Far East and ANE ancestry from Upper Paleolithic Siberian individuals.  Finer resolution population analysis showed that the genetic profiles of the individuals in this study comprised "a mixture of three major components that were mostly enriched in ANE-related individuals, northeast Asians, and central Siberians."  There was no inbreeding found in any of these individuals, although "runs of homozygosity" analysis suggested a smaller population size in Mesolithic northeastern Siberia.

    "Outgroup" statistics of the genetic information derived from these 19 individuals showed a "close genetic affinity with Native American and Beringian (i.e., from populations settled around the Bering Strait) populations," with differences most likely due to genetic drift in Native American populations from the ancestral ANE genotype.  In addition, "aside from the first wave migrating into the Americas through Beringia, the admixture modeling suggests that the source of the Native American ancestry was more broadly spread across Siberia during the Upper Paleolithic."  The data were also consistent with "this basal Native American group experienced multiple genetic contacts with northeast Asian populations giving rise to distinct ancient Siberian populations."

    With regard to the Siberian populations per se, the results of the genetic analyses set forth in this paper suggested a more prolonged period of population mixing in the Lake Bailal area, "between local groups and northeast Asian-related populations" occurring during the early Neolithic period.  And illustrating the granularity of the information that can be obtained from such studies, the authors report that one individual appears to have migrated from the Angara River Valley to the Lake Bailal region prior to being 7 years of age, based on the levels of 87Sr/86Sr in his teeth.

    Turning to the evidence of Y. pestis infection and its relevance to the population studies described in this paper, the authors reference prior research results showing such infections in Europe and central Asia between the Middle Neolithic period and the Bronze Age, spanning ~4,900 – 3,500 BP.  Two of the individuals (estimated to have lived 4,556 and 4,430 BP) studied by these authors had evidence of Y. pestis infection.  Genetic comparisons found the most similarity to a genome from the Baltic Sea, which was anomalous because these individuals were shown to be "genetic outliers" having relatively less steppe population-derived ancestry (which had been previously associated with Y. pestis infection).  The authors assert their data to provide the first "evidence for the presence of human Y. pestis infections in the Lake Baikal region during the Early Bronze Age," which is the eastern-most appearance of the disease in this time period.

    The authors provide several conclusions and interpretations of this information and analysis.  First, they contend that their data is evidence for "multiple population turnovers [having taken] place in the Lake Baikal region from the Upper Paleolithic to the Bronze Age periods as a dynamic variation of ANE and NEA ancestry proportions," and not a "complete replacement of the ANE-related ancestry by an East Asian gene pool," as had been previously suggested.  Rather, their data is consistent with there having been "a prolonged gene flow between NEA- and ANE-related ancestries throughout the eighth to the sixth millennium BP."

    Second, these genetic analyses provided evidence that non-Arctic Native Americans had a "strong genetic connection" with Upper Paleolithic Siberians, based on the genetic comparisons and similarities between "Native Americans, the 14,000-year-old southern Siberian . . . individual and the 9,800-year-old northeastern Siberian . . . individual," who appear to all have been descendants of "the same admixed population that carried both ANE and NEA ancestries [and] was likely widespread across Siberia during the Upper Paleolithic and experienced frequent genetic contacts with northeast Asian-related populations."  But rather than providing a definitive source of Native American ancestry from these groups, the authors state that while "our result[s] challenges the hypothesis that this basal Native American ancestry formed in northeastern Siberia,"[f]urther genetic evidence from Upper Paleolithic Siberian groups will be necessary to describe where and when exactly the ancestral gene pool of Native Americans came together."  These migrations are shown graphically in the paper:

    Image 2
    There evidence does show, in these authors' opinion, that there was "genetic contact between southern Siberia and the western steppe during the Early Bronze Age, based on both human and pathogen DNA data, which suggests a high mobility across Eurasia."  And the pathogen genetic data "may rather be indicative of a century- or decade-long process that lead to the bacterium's long-distance spread," which "most parsimoniously suggests that Y. pestis spread into this region within the context of . . . steppe expansions during the fifth millennium BP."

    The authors conclude the paper by stating that:

    [O]ur study describes dynamic changes in the population structure of the Lake Baikal region and reveals a widespread occurrence of the genetic ancestry that gave rise to the First People of the Americas in Upper Paleolithic Siberia.  In addition, we provide evidence of high human mobility across the Eurasian steppe revealing new insights about the spread of Y. pestis during the fifth millennium BP.

    * He Yu, Maria A. Spyrou, Marina Karapetian, Svetlana Shnaider, Rita Radzevičiūtė, Kathrin Nägele, Gunnar U. Neumann, Sandra Penske, Jana Zech, Mary Lucas, Petrus LeRoux, Patrick Roberts, Galina Pavlenok, Cosimo Posth, Choongwon Jeong (corresponding author), and Johannes Krause (corresponding author)

    Affiliations:  Max Planck Institute for Science of Human History; Siberian Branch Russian Academy of Sciences; University of Cape Town, South Africa; and Moscow State University

  • Life Sciences "Top 53"

    By Donald Zuhn —

    IPO #2Last week, the Intellectual Property Owners Association (IPO) and Harrity Analytics announced the release of the 37th annual list of the top 300 organizations receiving U.S. utility patents (see "Top 300 Organizations Granted U.S. Patents in 2019").  Patent Docs readers may recall that the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office stopped releasing its annual list of top patent recipients in 2006 in order to "discourag[e] any perception that we believe more is better."

    HarrityThis year, the report was compiled in collaboration with Harrity Analytics, based on data obtained from the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.  The IPO and Harrity Analytics noted that patents reported on the 2019 list are utility patents granted during the 2019 calendar year that listed the organization or a subsidiary as the owner on the printed patent document.  Harrity Analytics then used organization and subsidiary data provided to two independent third-party data providers and reviewed over 200,000 assignments to attribute ownership to the correct organizations, where applicable.  The report notes that patents that were granted to two or more organizations jointly are attributed to each organization separately, and that companies for which patents were granted to subsidiaries are combined with patents granted to the parent.

    The IPO and Harrity Analytics also noted that 354,507 patents were issued in 2019, which was a 15.2% increase from the 307,759 patents that issued in 2018.  The top fifteen companies on the IPO Top 300 are listed below (click on table to expand):

    2019 Top 15
    Dell, Qualcomm, and Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing fell out of the Top 15 in 2019.  Dell dropped from 12th to 16th, Qualcomm dropped from 10th to 17th, and Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing dropped from 8th to 18th in 2019.  Jumping into the Top 15 were Huawei (19th to 7th), Sony (18th to 11th), and Amazon (16th to 15th).

    As in past years, Patent Docs used the IPO's list of top patent holders to compile a list of the top "life sciences" companies and organizations receiving U.S. utility patents in 2019.  Each organization's IPO top 300 ranking for 2019 is indicated in the "2019 IPO Rank" column; the IPO top 300 ranking for 2018 (if available) is indicated in the "2018 IPO Rank" column; and the change in number of patents from 2018 is indicated in "% Change from 2018."  The Life Sciences Top 53 is listed below (click on table to expand):

    2019 Top 50
    Please note that some of the companies and organizations listed above may be involved in work outside the life sciences sector, and therefore, a portion of the patents granted to these companies and organizations may be directed to other than life sciences-related inventions.  Our list also includes medical device companies.  In addition, the report indicates that the data for 2019 for each individual organization could be affected by mergers, acquisitions, divestitures, inconsistent treatment of subsidiaries in 2018 and 2019, and many other factors.  Thus, while nine members of the Life Sciences Top 53 were not listed in the 2018 Top 300, they were not listed by the IPO and Harrity Analytics in the 2019 Top 300 as "new" additions to the list.  These nine companies and organizations are indicated in the table above by an asterisk ("*") in the 2018 IPO Rank column to distinguish them from new additions to the list (listed as "new" in the same column).

    For additional information regarding this topic, please see:

    • "IPO Releases List of Top 300 Patent Holders for 2018," August 7, 2019
    • "IPO Releases List of Top 300 Patent Holders for 2017," July 4, 2018
    • "IPO Releases List of Top 300 Patent Holders for 2016," June 14, 2017
    • "IPO Releases List of Top 300 Patent Holders for 2014," July 1, 2015
    • "IPO Releases List of Top 300 Patent Holders for 2013," July 7, 2014
    • "IPO Releases List of Top 300 Patent Holders for 2012," June 24, 2013
    • "Another Look at IPO Top 300 and Life Sciences Top 53," June 11, 2012
    • "IPO Releases List of Top 300 Patent Holders for 2011," June 7, 2012
    • "IPO Releases List of Top 300 Patent Holders for 2010," June 30, 2011
    • "IPO Releases List of Top 300 Patent Holders for 2009," May 26, 2010
    • "IPO Releases List of Top 300 Patent Holders for 2008," May 14, 2009
    • "IPO Releases List of Top 300 Patent Holders," May 22, 2008
    • "IPO Posts List of Top 300 Patent Holders," April 20, 2007

  • CalendarMay 26, 2020 – "Innovation and Incentive Systems" (Federal Circuit Bar Association) – 11:00 am to 12:00 pm (EST)

    May 26, 2020 – "Licensing and Collaborations: Common Pitfalls and Best Practice" (Lexology Webinars, iam, and Potter Clarkson) – 11:00 am to 12:00 pm (EDT)

    May 26, 2020 – "Modern Patent Research: Capitalizing on Information Across Your Organization" (Derwent and IPWatchdog) – 12:00 pm (EDT)

    May 26, 2020 – "Trade Secret Litigation 101: What All Attorneys Should Know as Employees Work from Home and Jobless Claims Continue to Rise" (Federal Bar Association and MyLawCLE) – 3:00 to 4:00 pm (ET)

    May 27, 2020 – "Key findings from the IAM Benchmarking Survey 2020" (IPBC Talking Heads and iam) – 11:00 am to 12:00 pm (EDT)

    May 27, 2020 – "Innovating Our Way Through the Coronavirus Pandemic" (KPMG and Schwegman Lundberg & Woessner) – 1:00 to 2:00 pm (CT)

    May 28, 2020 – "How to Develop and Maintain a World Class Patent Portfolio" (LexisNexis and IPWatchdog) – 12:00 pm (ET)

    May 28, 2020 – "Artificial Intelligence: Challenges and Opportunities" (Federal Circuit Bar Association) – 1:00 to 2:00 pm (EST)

  • Federal Circuit Bar Association_2The Federal Circuit Bar Association (FCBA) will be offering a remote program entitled "Artificial Intelligence: Challenges and Opportunities" on May 28, 2020 from 1:00 to 2:00 pm (EST).  Patrick Keane of Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney PC will moderate a panel consisting of Uren Chen of Qualcomm Inc.; Ron Dimock of Gowling WLG; Laura Sheridan of Google LLC; and Coke Stewart, Acting Chief of Staff and Senior Policy Advisor, U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.  The panel will discuss the role of Al as Industrial Revolution 4.0 unfolds, including the key challenges and opportunities presented by Al within the tech community, how the legal community is evolving in response, particularly with regard to issues of inventorship, patentability, and enforcement, and the role of Al in the current COVID crisis.

    The webinar is complimentary for FCBA members and students, $25 for government and students, or $75 for private practitioners.  Those interested in registering for the program, can do so here.

  • LexisNexisLexisNexis and IPWatchdog will be offering a webinar entitled "How to Develop and Maintain a World Class Patent Portfolio" on May 28, 2020 at 12:00 pm (ET).  Gene Quinn of IPWatchdog, Prof. James Gerard Conley of Kellogg School of Management at Northwestern University, Prof. Holger Ernst of WHU – Otto Beisheim School of Management, Jens Bördin of Konsert Strategy & IP, and Marco Richter of PatentSight – LexisNexis will discuss how to implement processes in organizations to develop and maintain such a world-class patent portfolio, as well as the requirements for software applications that are capable to provide the required insights into innovation and give examples of how smart tools can be utilized to maintain world class patent portfolios.

    There is no registration fee for this webinar.  However, those interested in registering for the webinar, should do so here.

  • KPMGKPMG and Schwegman Lundberg & Woessner will be offering a webinar entitled "Innovating Our Way Through the Coronavirus Pandemic" on May 27, 2020 from 1:00 to 2:00 pm (CT).  Amol Gavankar of KPMG, Piers Blewett of Schwegman Lundberg & Woessner, Jim Sulciner of Sulciner Group, and François deVilliers of Schwegman Lundberg & Woessner will discuss practical steps for sparking innovation, harvesting IP, and optimizing R&D tax credit.

    While there is no cost to participate in the program, those interested in attending the webinar can register here.

  • Federal Circuit Bar Association_2The Federal Circuit Bar Association (FCBA) will be offering a remote program entitled "Innovation and Incentive Systems" on May 26, 2020 from 11:00 am to 12:00 pm (EST).  Laura Masurovsky of Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner, LLP will moderate a panel consisting of  Eb Bright of the Alliance of U.S. Startups & Inventors for Jobs (USU); Bill Harmon, Director, IP and Trademarks, Uber Technologies, Inc.; Philip Hirschhorn of Panitch Schwarze Belisario & Nadel LLP; and Liane Peterson of Foley & Lardner LLP.  The panel will discuss the types of incentives (and disincentives) that exist in the Global IP community and their impact on innovation.  The panelists will also discuss their viewpoints including:

    • Medtech perspective on innovation and incentives with an overview from startup ecosystems to aggregators to investors, focusing on practical experience and experience with what works and what does not.
    • Recent PTO initiatives related to promoting new COVID-19 treatments on the market more quickly, discussion of the COVID-19 Prioritized Examination Trial Program and the Patents 4 Partnerships IP marketplace platform.
    • Tech perspective and global incentive systems from different vantage points, discussion of compulsory reward system in China and comparison to other systems in terms of impact on innovation.
    • Inventor incentives globally, importance of certainty in marketplace for IP, discussion of laws, e.g., antitrust laws, that incentivize or discourage innovation or add to the uncertainty investors and patentees lace.

    The webinar is complimentary for FCBA members and students, $25 for government and students, or $75 for private practitioners.  Those interested in registering for the program, can do so here.

  • IAMLexology Webinars, iam, and Potter Clarkson will be offering a free webinar entitled "Licensing and Collaborations: Common Pitfalls and Best Practice" on May 26, 2020 from 11:00 am to 12:00 pm (EDT).  Intellectual property licensing experts Oliver Laing and Mark Snelgrove will explore deal-making best practice and common pitfalls to avoid, focusing on protecting and maximising the value of your intellectual property.

    Those interested in registering for the webinar, can do so here.

  • DerwentDerwent and IPWatchdog will be offering a webinar entitled "Modern Patent Research: Capitalizing on Information Across Your Organization" on May 26, 2020 at 12:00 pm (EDT).  Gene Quinn of IPWatchdog, Vashe Kanesarajah of Clarivate Analytics, Debra Banville of Dupont, and Benoit Sollie of Cargill will discuss lessons about patent research learned from top-performing companies and what should be considered to adapt and evolve traditional models to current informational best practices.

    There is no registration fee for this webinar.  However, those interested in registering for the webinar, should do so here.

  • MyLawCLEThe Federal Bar Association and MyLawCLE will be offering a video CLE webinar entitled "Trade Secret Litigation 101: What All Attorneys Should Know as Employees Work from Home and Jobless Claims Continue to Rise" on May 26, 2020 from 3:00 to 4:00 pm (ET).  Michael T. Renaud and Nicholas W. Armington will provide an overview of trade secret litigation, including the scope of what qualifies as a trade secret under the Defend Trade Secrets Act and state trade secret statutes, what qualifies as reasonable measures to maintain the secrecy of trade secret information, and protections available to trade secret owners through the Defend Trade Secrets Act and state trade secret statutes.  The webinar will also discuss economic and social drivers of a likely increase in trade secret litigation in the coming years resulting from the ubiquitous work-from-home arrangements due to social-distancing requirements in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic and the present economic downturn, and discuss steps businesses can take to protect their trade secrets, including preventative measures against misappropriation including risk factors to be aware of, and responsive steps for businesses to take where misappropriation has already occurred.

    The registration fee for the webinar is $95.  Those interested in registering for the webinar can do so here.